← Back to context

Comment by atleastoptimal

1 day ago

Anthropic was sued successfully for training on books, the law still applies to them

https://www.npr.org/2025/09/05/g-s1-87367/anthropic-authors-...

When I write fizzbuzz do I owe royalties to the inventor of fizzbuzz? Is my brain copyright thieving because I can write out the song lyrics from memory?

They got sued for downloading pirated books and not for using them for training. Huge difference.

  • Indeed, the court actually explicitly held that Anthropic had the right to train their AIs on books, so long as they paid for them.

I think if you write fizzbuzz and then sell it, without attribution, and it goes against the original fizzbuzz license, then you’re infringing.