← Back to context

Comment by znpy

16 hours ago

Gitlab is pretty cool to be honest, and it’s generally underrated.

I agree, but it does have faults. Performance is woeful, and managing an on-prem instance is (literally) a full time job.

  • > managing an on-prem instance is (literally) a full time job.

    Hosting a Docker container is a full-time job? I have worked at several employers self-hosting their own instances without issues or a lot of effort. Many FOSS projects do, that definitely do not have a full-time guy for that. What are you talking about?

    • Hundreds or 10k+ users?

      I imagine requirements and integrations may differ a lot. I have seen many incidents with a large instance.

  • yeah that is true. i did manage a gitlab instance for ~100 developers (between 2019 and 2022) and yeah performance was shit. not gonna lie, i blame ruby for that.

    if you accept the performance hit, it's great quality software though.

    however, a fairly large company with 100-120 users (developers, devops engineers, QAs etc) and ~600 gitlab runners ran happily on a 8 core / 64gb virtual machine (hosted on a local vmware cluster).

    so it is (was?) also fairly cheap.