Comment by xyzelement
15 hours ago
// We later learned that sadly only 6% of Southwest pilots are women,
I am not sure that's a "sadly". I used to fly a lot and talk to flight crews. Aviation is a ton of crazy schedules and nights away from home (I assume this is well known)
From a family perspective it's bad enough if dads missing from the house for days at a time, much more catastrophic if mom's not around like that.
(A child's relationship with mom vs. dad is very different. Kids need their mom in a very different way that we can't just paper over)
> From a family perspective it's bad enough if dads missing from the house for days at a time, much more catastrophic if mom's not around like that.
Ah, what is so special that women bring that men can't? Neither women or men are fundamental to raising a child, parents are. Gay couples raise healthy, well-adjusted children all the time without one or the other gender as a parent.
Positioning a family as having women-at-home as a requirement just sounds like old-school misogyny to me. (And also de-valuing the capability of men.) Men are perfectly capable of filling this domestic role as well.
Fair - how does that account for the predominantly female FA population?
FAs have very interesting schedules. As they work up seniority they have a ton of flexibility in how they space apart their required minimum number of shifts/overnights. Trading shifts and bidding for shifts is common. Additionally at some point in their seniority ladder they can start getting a regular set of shifts that get them back home to base daily, with occasional overnights.
I suspect this institutional flexibility is actually a natural consequence of the gendered nature of the role.
I don't think FA is a great job for a mom but it's not as horrible as pilot. FAs can switch shifts between themselves and dial up or down their hours with relative ease. Pilots have a lot less of this flexibility.
The schedules have negligible difference with respect to your original argument. So if busy schedules are why there are hardly any women pilots, why is the gender balance the exact opposite for flight attendants? There are reasons, and they aren't all because "men bad", but your initial argument is 100% not true based on the simple counterexample of flight attendants. What is being "papered over" is this: why, given the same schedules, are women under-represented in the higher paying, higher prestige job?
1 reply →
What evidence is this claim based on?
forgive me if I am wrong, but this comment sounds like we are trying to build a narrative. I might be wrong. No offense.
Not sure the point. I was citing the article and sharing my reaction. What are you doing with the royal we?
[dead]
Is “build a narrative” code for something? The comment was pretty cut and dry as written.
"Narrative" is the code word people use when they want to act coy and not say what they really think. Edgy vagueness.
The "sadly" comment in the article is also a narrative. No offense.
It isn't a narrative, it is simply a point of view. Are we happy there aren't more women pilots? That would be your POV.
1 reply →