Comment by Dylan16807

> I do not see why someone else should be able to tell you (a business or person) who you have to allow access to your computers and your bandwidth that you pay for.

The spirit of the law isn't to tell you that, it's to limit how much you can track people without their consent.

> Costco has the right to verify my identity when I walk into their store, I don't see why computing resources would be different.

That falls under "Verifying identity for specific services tied to your finances or body". You bought a membership, they're checking your membership.

If it was a store without a membership, then for practical purposes in real life we let them look at your ID but they shouldn't be allowed to record any identifying data off of it. When it's all done by machines we should use cryptography to make it anonymous from the start.