← Back to context

Comment by tetha

13 hours ago

How do you define flawless though?

The CVEs here have their fair share of silly C problems, but also more rigid input validation and handling. These more rigid validations exclude stuff which may even be valid by the spec, but entirely problematic in practice.

As examples, take a look how many valid XML documents are practically considered unsafe and not parsed, for example due to recursive entity expansion. This renders the parsers not flawless and in fact not in spec.

Or, my favorite bait - there should be a maximum length limit on passwords. Why would you ever need a kilobyte sized password?