← Back to context

Comment by vessenes

5 hours ago

That would be nice, but it's not going to be possible.

Any open benchmark has a very short life, since it will be pulled in and DPO / RL trained quickly for benchmaxxing purposes. So, you'll need a private test to have a hope of something fair. (These also get leaked over time, btw, so even then there's a window of usability).

These are expensive to run.

Now consider that there might be 15-20 viable quants for a given open model release; someone would have to want to pay for these private evals to be run on them. Even then, a good read through unsloth's commits and blog posts will remind you that there's quite a lot of engineering work to be done to get model inference working properly, even for models released by frontier or near-frontier labs. So, you'd want to make sure that you have a replicable 'best engineered' deployment to evaluate, or at least one that's closest to your hardware and fits the bill.

Upshot - it's much faster to download and try out a model, and possibly cheaper too. Well, cheaper since hugging face is paying the bandwidth bills.