← Back to context

Comment by ikeboy

2 hours ago

The magistrate judge is supposed to be a check on that power. Unfortunately, they've become rubber stamps for the most part. In a functioning system, the judge would block the warrant and arrest.

I think there are ways to have a system where judges do that, without having to criminally prosecute either cops or judges.

> In a functioning system, the judge would block the warrant and arrest.

But they lied to obtain the warrant.

  • OP says that they left out information (which cops do all the time) but that the warrant shouldn't have been granted either way because of SCOTUS precedent.

    Would welcome reform that makes it harder to lie on warrant affidavits, although again, that should be civil in nature.

    • > they left out information

      Yes, we call that lying by omission.

      They knew that information would result in the warrant not being granted, so they left it out.

      2 replies →