Comment by sanity

3 days ago

What would your success metric be for whether reusing the name was the right decision?

Community size and positive community feedback, which is somewhat tangential to progress, which I assume is in the context of development. Also, the rate at which the original freenet community declines.

Number of contributors or pull requests isn't a good metric at the moment since the advent of Claude Code et al. has seen a dramatic uptick in both everywhere.

  • How is it tangential? Technical success is the primary driver of community growth, adoption, and long-term viability. The more it can do, and the better it does it, the more people will use it.

    • Community growth might imply technical success (debatable), but technical success does not imply community growth.

      You can have a very technically successful project, but it doesn't mean it'll be used.

      1 reply →