Comment by jordanb
12 hours ago
I used Google Translate to not learn French in collage. Fortunately for me it was bad enough I had to carefully review all its outputs, but that still didn't help and I managed to pass two semesters without ever developing even basic language skills.
Something radical needs to be done. When I was in high school there were still a lot of "no calculator" restrictions in my math classes that I chaffed at because I hated doing longform arithmetic and felt like it got in the way of learning. So I can certainly understand how students would chafe at some kind of paper-only education system but I also don't see how you can learn anything when you have a high-quality homework machine just sitting there.
I wish that would have worked for me - we had oral tests. 2 years of French in high school and one semester at college - what an absolute waste of time. How much French do I know now? Basically none. The same goes for everyone in my life that did Spanish instead in high school.
Part of what we could do during this upset is re-prioritize.
Wow, really?
I took four years of Spanish in high school, and thirty-ish years later I can hold basic conversations with people, ask for things, answer their questions.
All that's needed is a tight feedback loop between learning and applying those skills ... the thing that Google Translate helped you evade. AI can be a tool for evading or optimizing that loop, like a knife can cut your sandwich or your throat. Your choice.
It's the "your choice" that's the problem. The quality of a society is dominated by the choices that other people make.