Comment by piterrro
11 hours ago
> GET request with a body was heavily considered by the IETF working group, but it was ultimately rejected in favor of creating the new QUERY method. The decision to create a distinct method came down to historical interoperability issues and strict compliance with the core architectural definitions of HTTP.
I've been sending request body along GET method for years now
Apparently some load balancers drop the body.
I expect all sorts of intermediaries may drop the body, since having a body is forbidden by the standard.
When it's your client talking to your server you can obviously do whatever you want - it doesn't cause problems until you want to involve third-party code, such as a reverse proxy (such as nginx) or a CDN. This includes proxies your customers may be using.
Where is it forbidden by the standard? I don't see anything in the GET definition in RFC 9110 [1] forbidding that. My understanding was that this is just undefined behavior. And not recommended due to your point about some third-party CDNs and RPs handling that UB in different ways.
[1]: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/rfc9110#name-get
1 reply →
> I've been sending request body along GET method for years now
Generally not a great idea. With some http implementations this is not even possible (for example, fetch)
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/Fetch_API/U...
> You cannot include a body with GET requests
And transparent caching might result in weird issues.