← Back to context

Comment by jayGlow

9 hours ago

Does he not meet the criteria of a famous professor?

Maybe you could start with an actual practicing scientist. One problem you're going to run into here is that, as I said, this is an active area of study. If these papers are firing offenses, someone ought to be telling HR.

  • Person 1: give me an example of someone who was kicked out of academia for uncomfortable truths.

    Person 2: [gives examples]

    Person 1: oh ho! But those people are not in academia any more! They're not "practicing scientists"!

    Person 2: ...

    • Yes, me and my Calvinball rule of "actual scientist prevented from publishing on this subject".

      There's a kind of Schneierism thing that happens in these threads; like: I could ask, ok, name a scientist practicing in this field. They exist, but they don't have names your 3rd grade science teacher knows.