← Back to context

Comment by LoganDark

8 hours ago

> claude, gemini and chatgpt are very good at communicating

There is no communication there. No concepts for them to communicate. It is just math.

5 comments

LoganDark

Reply
nfw2  8 hours ago

Regardless of the implementation, claude causes concepts to enter my brain, so it is at least one-way communication. Human brains have mundane implementations as well: chemical signals firing across neural synapses. No magic special sauce, at least not that we can detect

  • bavell  6 hours ago

    My rock collection causes concepts to enter my brain, but I don't think I'd say they're communicating with me, nor I with them.

  • LoganDark  7 hours ago

    I would say you communicate to the model and you interpret the model's outputs. I would not say the model communicates back though.

    I'm not sure that models are complex enough to have a consistent internal representation of a concept the same way that organic brains can to communicate. I'm not sure of any quantitative science backing this up though. Models don't know anything across iterations yet.