Comment by qarl2
15 days ago
HackerNews is now censoring my replies. I did the math - all of these patches would have cost around $100.
Let's see if they'll let this account through.
15 days ago
HackerNews is now censoring my replies. I did the math - all of these patches would have cost around $100.
Let's see if they'll let this account through.
It's like you are not even reading what is being said to you. You can't find the downstream effects using grep!
You can find the "strncpy"s with grep, but you cannot find all the downstream effect of those changes, especially if something downstream is relying on the broken behaviour!
Right. I am not claiming Claude Code creates perfect software. I am refuting your claim that using it would be cost prohibitive.
I took the 10 most difficult patches from the git history - the ones that took the most back-and-forth to fix. I asked Claude to write them. Would you like to see the work?
If you believe a human performs better at finding downstream effects - you need to prove that. I see no reason why it should be true.
> If you believe a human performs better at finding downstream effects
Once gain, you are not reading what is being said - no one made that claim!
No claim was made in fact: it was a refutation. Specifically, the refutation is "this is why it took so many years".
1 reply →