← Back to context

Comment by godwinson__4-8

2 hours ago

You're cute too.

So you accomplished all these things and yet the country is broken?

I'm confused. Did you not get everything you wanted fast enough? How sad :(

It's my hobby! some people like 3d printing or trolling on the internet.

I like to prevent my city council to implement more surveillance and expose how cosy they are with the companies selling said surveillance.

>So you accomplished all these things and yet the country is broken

Yes. Those things are meaningless in the face of 3 letter agency capability or broad stroke regulation like FISA (recent big win by the folks at RT4 there, normies have not heard of it but those people did a great job at influencing republican politician )

> Did you not get everything you wanted fast enough? How sad :(

I mostly want privacy, for myself and the people who seek it.

I don't find that too much to ask in a country that is fast to point the finger at China "dystopian level of surveillance"

10 years is a sizeable slice of life. Their was some progress and wins. And those days the zeitgeist is on our side.

But its sad yes.

  • If Men were angels, no government would be necessary.

    Sadness is part of life. I actually respect the work you do, your own obvious condescension aside ("normies" and so forth). I guess we can allow it given this is probably a typical attitude of those who are deeply enmeshed in these issues while others just go on about their lives.

    I simply ask you to consider the counterfactual to your original articulation in this thread.

    If one or a handful of people showing up could simply change the law or the prevailing order by the force of their minority stamina alone that would not be a desirable society, now would it? As someone who has been to more than a few city council meetings you have surely encountered some of these people. In your case, I would too wish the path was easier. But if you could get everything you wanted right away then doing so would open the door to any crackpot. There is normative value in making change hard, even if in specific cases, this comes across as cruelty, corruption, and so forth. We could do a lot worse. Government in large part exists because people favor corruption over bloodshed. Are you any different? What is today your hobby was something some ancestor of yours doubtlessly lost their lives over. It is fine to be a little demoralized now and again, but let us not spread the gospel of the needlessly catastrophic. Such an outlook is highly disrespectful to the reality of our collective situation and our history.

    If you have an alternative formulation to govern man, which is somehow neither resistant to your own ideas, nor any opposition of your neighbors, please describe it.

    Until then:

    Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time...