← Back to context

Comment by fishgoesblub

1 day ago

> since it isn't being compressed

Isn't being compressed as much. All Blurays are compressed either with MPEG2, VC1, H.264, or H.265 if it's an UHD Bluray.

Huh, I always thought they were uncompressed. That's why people preferred it over hd-dvd

  • Uncompressed 24-bit 1080p running at 24 FPS requires 1.192 Gbit/s, or 0.149 GByte/s. So a 25 GB (single-layer) blu-ray has enough space for a whopping 167.8 seconds of uncompressed 1080p video running at 24 FPS. You can double that with a dual-layer blu-ray, and there are more corners you can cut, but I don't think you'll fit your movie in there.

    Video is really big. Compression was needed to make it even vaguely possible unless your quality was in the toilet.

    HD-DVDs were smaller, so they were more compressed.

    • I don’t think that you guys should be debating compressed vs uncompressed, but lossy compression vs lossless compression. Your math seems to derive from a naive storage format.

      3 replies →