← Back to context

Comment by Schiendelman

5 days ago

It can't, because it isn't training your heart and cardiovascular system.

Well, it's causing muscle contractions. At high enough intensity, it should raise your heart rate. It's just a matter of what intensity level is tolerable during sleep (and the effect on sleep quality), no?

  • No, that would wake you up long before it had cardiovascular benefit. You need your heart rate up into zone 2 to 5 to really have a positive impact. That's 120 BPM plus for most people. Once you're around 80 it'll wake up anyone, even someone with very low cardiovascular fitness.

    • I read with the right dream (nightmare) heart rate can climb to 180.

      If you slowly condition yourself I think you can exchange sleep quality for increased heart rate.

      But I suspect the heart needs rest too and you will die.

      An isometric hold would be better I think. You don't get any vo2max improvement but it does improve cardiovascular health.

      2 replies →

    • > Once you're around 80 it'll wake up anyone

      Source? I haven't been able to find info on this. I get resuls on nocturnal tachycardia and such. Nothing on elevating a sleeping person's heart rate and observing the result, though.

      1 reply →