← Back to context

Comment by slopinthebag

1 day ago

Why don’t you just google ecosocialism? Read the wiki entry? Is that too difficult?

Here:

Elmar Altvater

Ian Angus

Rudolph Bahro

Adam Bandt

Hugo Blanco

Murray Bookchin

Jabari Brisport

Walt Brown

Paul Burkett

Max Chandler-Mather

Barry Commoner

Jeremy Corbyn

Pat Devine

Jutta Ditfurth

Sabrina Fernandes

John Bellamy Foster

Alberto Garzón

André Gorz

Ramachandra Guha

Donna Haraway

Howie Hawkins

Jason Hickel

Joan Herrera i Torres

Naomi Klein

Mark Carney

Joel Kovel

Dimitri Lascaris

Enrique Leff

Michael Löwy

Caroline Lucas

Andreas Malm

David McReynolds

Jean-Luc Mélenchon

Steven Guilbeault

Chico Mendes

Luka Mesec

George Monbiot

William Morris

Abdullah Öcalan

James O'Connor

David Orton

Simon Pirani

Zack Polanski

Lee Rhiannon

Raül Romeva

Manuel Sacristán

Ariel Salleh

Joan Saura

Pernille Skipper

Jill Stein

Chlöe Swarbrick

Alan Thornett

Peter Tatchell

Alex Tyrrell

Derek Wall

Raymond Williams

Gerrard Winstanley

Avi Lewis

Maybe 6 of those people hold any kind of actual government position. The rest are either not in politics, former, retired from government, or dead. So ~six people control automobile regulation worldwide and are forcing people out of cars.... Right?

  • You do understand that's an incomplete list of prominent eco-socialists, not literally every single believer right?

    • Then why didn't you provide a list of the ones who are doing "their work"? Given how many people talk about this, supposedly with hard evidence (that's never, ultimately, presented), someone must have compiled such a list, tied the individuals to the policies they've effected, mapped out their influence, the coalitions and deals… and if you believe this for good reason, then you must have had access to this proof.

      On the other hand, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eco-socialism#Critique_of_actu... says:

      > Kovel believes that the forms of 'actually existing socialism' consisted of "public ownership of the means of production", rather than meeting "the true definition" of socialism as "a free association of producers", with the Party-State bureaucracy acting as the "alienating substitute 'public'".[130]

      and in general, I cannot find any examples of eco-socialists making the claims, or holding the beliefs, you're attributing to them. Eco-socialists are not, near as I can tell, a fan of the state, nor "government ownership".

      3 replies →