← Back to context

Comment by nottorp

12 hours ago

> making it inclusive to the long-time users on the site, but exclusive to the newbie participants

I used to look for questions to answer on my morning coffee. Then two things happened:

1. Rep chasers that rushed to answer anything with a copy/pasta from manuals (or at best semi related tutorials) showed up so there was no point or time in typing a complex answer.

2. Those long time users started downmodding "teach the man how to fish" answers and favoring "here's stuff ready to copy/paste" answers.

This was long before LLMs.

At least 50% of the time on SO, the best answer is 3rd or worse, and I'm always thinking, "Why is this not the top answer?"

  • Because the person who asked the question has accepted the first answer that looked decent enough and moved on.

    Usually the most superficial, not that it's always a bad thing.

    Oh, also on SO there's this kind of exchange:

    Q: "I want to do X because of this and that - or because I simply fucking want to".

    A: You should never do X, do Y or Z instead.

  • I might even find an upside in that if it wasn't for the fact that this stolen crowd sourced knowledge will be used to make some billionaires even richer.