Comment by notpushkin
6 days ago
No X. No Y. A is your B.
We do G, not H. C, D, E — plus an optional F.
No I, no J, no K — just an L into a W.
I would say the design is the most human thing about this page. (It has its charm somehow, even if it’s obviously “flavour of the week LLM design”. Also, I don’t think an LLM would choose colours so poorly unless nudged in that direction – accidentally, I suppose.)
Oh no, concise sentences.
Must be an inappropriate use of the robot!
Kind of exhausting.
If you think (or care), that the LLM wrote all of the subheaders, the category names etc, then you might be spending too much time focused on the wrong thing.
> If you think (or care)
I don’t think anybody really cares, the reaction is because you praised some copy that was obviously written by an LLM and either not edited or barely edited.
There was barely anything to edit, and I think they did a great job choosing what NOT to write out on the lander.
Sometimes less is more.
4 replies →
I don’t really care. I’m just... disappointed a bit? It seems like a cool project, but those “concise sentences” don’t make it easier to learn about it.
No accounts? How is that possible? You literally store my data! Is that not an account?
And what the fuck is OAuth? (Okay, this clearly is oriented at developers, but on its own the sentence just doesn’t make sense. For me as a user, what pain is removed by not having a “Sign in with GitHub” button? Why should I care?)
How about you tell me why you decided to do it that way:
It took me a couple of minutes to write this, sure, but at least it now makes sense. And it’s more concise, no? (It still sounds llm-y to me, but whatever.)
Now, for bonus points, there’s two obvious questions to answer:
• what do I do if I lose my SSH key?
• what do I do if I use more than one device?
(The obvious answers are “you can add other SSH keys in your account settings” and “you can add other SSH keys in your account settings”.)
---
Okay, one more, and then I need to go grab a beer.
Concise?
I like your last improvement, for sure.
The goal of the lander is to get you to use the clubhouse.
Not get you to become a contributor, or intrigued/turned away by their stack choice.
PS You could also be a heathen, and use the same key across devices!
1 reply →