Comment by mmmasterggg
3 days ago
For me, the problem was never the writing of the code. Building something takes care and rigor. Software development got where it is through years of accumulated practice: habits first, then safeguards, then structures that had actually been proven. Now people set the code aside and just describe their problem, and they have no real sense of what comes back, because nobody can review output produced that fast. Nobody is even keeping up with the systems we built to help us keep up. So we ship without quite knowing what we shipped, and the sloppiness follows from that.
Isn't that how it's gone before, though? People used to make beautiful furniture by hand and leave something of themselves in it. Now it comes out of a factory, nobody knows exactly which part they made, they just fit pieces together, and it isn't built to last. Software is at that same point: nobody knows exactly what they've made or how. They describe the problem, assume they've found the solution, ship it, and there is no undoing it. The sloppiness will keep compounding. But that is also the point where people start thinking much harder about how to make it good again. A cycle, I suppose.
> Nobody is even keeping up with the systems we built to help us keep up. So we ship without quite knowing what we shipped, and the sloppiness follows from that.
NPM left-pad incident was a decade ago. Supply chain attacks have been a thing for longer than that (one of the first proposed SBOM's was around that time).
Source forge was shoving adware into the software from their site.
Asking an AI to write code is not worse than typing in PIP/NPM install (not to slight those tools) if you aren't going to code review either.
[flagged]
If furniture was still built like it was in the past you'd have about 2 pieces of it unless you were fabulously wealthy.
This is pretty true for software, how much have you actually paid for recently? FOSS isn't free either, a massive amount of time and coordination is required to make good software there too and few are willing to give it.
[dead]