← Back to context

Comment by amazingamazing

10 hours ago

Good. Most tech unions are worthless and only accelerate outsourcing. Unions can be good though, like in construction where the work is inherently dangerous.

Here's the union's demands. [1] Which of them do you find particularly unreasonable?

[1] https://wikiworkersunited.org/focus-areas/

  • > Hold management accountable to promises made to staff

    This is just silly. Management are the most accountable people in any organization. This makes no sense.

    • They are held accountable, but are they held accountable to the staff? If so, how-so?

      In my experience, management rarely has any sort of reverse checks in place. The closest is employee manager feedback. Which this demand

      > Guarantee ability to safely express dissent

      Makes me think that staff has been trained not to share true feelings on such feedback.

    • Hahahahahahahahahahahahha. Tell another joke

      I have never worked a place where management was even remotely held accountable for their decisions, their corruption, their abuse of power or their fecklessness.

      Unions now; unions tomorrow; unions forever.

How are unions worthless? First they can prevent unsustainable growth. Wikipedia doesn't need to grow, second they prevent exploitation of the worker, why should some random person treat wikipedia as their personal lottery wikipedia wasn't a new, or good, or well executed idea. It's a basic service that helps collate information.

What's wrong with outsourcing? That's what we do with all our bad ideas. Need to blow leaves from one side of the street to the other? Get a Mexican to do it. This frees up people to have better ideas, like well written articles that don't have a hundred irrelevant links littering the page.

  • This comment is pretty representative of why tech unions are worthless. Form a union to stop growth, and you pay your hard earned salary into such an organization with these goals?

    • Read WP:CANCER, there's a good argument. Wikipedia keeps spending its donations on useless stuff and therefore needs more and more donations each year. If it just stuck to running Wikipedia and a few side things, it would already be funded for 1000 years.

yes, yes, blame the victims. It's always the fault of the pedestrian for being in the road.