Comment by onion2k
3 hours ago
Baking the base models on to ROM makes a lot of economic sense.
Less so for consumers though, because it'd mean the phone is out of date in 3 months when a better model comes along.
3 hours ago
Baking the base models on to ROM makes a lot of economic sense.
Less so for consumers though, because it'd mean the phone is out of date in 3 months when a better model comes along.
It's a perfect reason to get consumers to buy a new phone every year again! They got bored of the camera.
This stopped working some years ago.
Now you sell the same phone with higher price tag.
I don’t think average user _needs_ to solve frontier challenges. ”Call to Jane”, ”turn on the lights” and ”what’s the weather this afternoon” is more like it I would guess.
Ofc if the model has some critical bugs that’s another matter.
Your examples worked on phones for over a decade.
Maybe baking in a model that is "certified" to have some unconditioned truths + rest is pulled from external models/store could make sense. But AFAIK that doesn't exist and I'm not sure it can possibly be made. Perhaps society as a whole at least can work on an open corpus of training data, but I'm not holding my breath on this.
>Your examples worked on phones for over a decade.
Nope. And not only not a decade ago, right now.
If you have an Android or iPhone, you can give it clear and easy to understand instructions that Gemma 4 could complete[1] if it had tool calls on it, and that 100.00% of Claude, ChatGPT, Grok, Kimi, you name it, could understand and all complete if they had the access.
The phones will fail to complete it. I just tried Siri. I said "hey Siri", waited for Siri to come up, and then I asked one of the exact sentences you replied to: "what's the weather this afternoon?" It thought for around 20 seconds, and said "Something went wrong. Please try again."[2]
I have Wifi, I have mobile Internet, I have free storage space, I have up to date software. What went wrong is that phones have never properly connected agents, not ten years ago, not last year, not this year, and probably not next year.
But don't settle for what Google could do in 1999 by hotlinking the keyword "weather" in any query to the weather being shown in the results.
Tell your phone (any phone): "Please call back the last number that called me that is not an unlisted number, regardless of who it came from."
0 out of any phone will complete that today, tomorrow, a year from now, five years from now, ever, because phone makers are not going to let them do that.
Meanwhile, 100% of all frontier agents could complete it if they had tool calls on the phone. Which they don't, and won't ever, thanks to the duopoly.
Okay, that's a bit dismissive, I would love to be wrong!
[1] after any voice recognition to text - which does work really well on both Android and iPhone! [2] screenshot: https://ibb.co/21rtDnfV
And the customers can wait for the new phone released next year. These are edge models - the average customer doesn’t need the latest frontier model. Just needs to be good enough for the features you promised.
That's a software engineering problem. They just need to figure out how to fine-tune for alignment and tool usage.
That's the only thing the normie consumer cares for really.