← Back to context

Comment by pessimizer

13 hours ago

This is some pseudo-profound Third Way radical centrist horseshit.

> Consider two categories of people:

> 1. The number of people in the general population who will object to Marxism.

> 2. The number of people in the general population who will know enough about the history and philosophy of economics to give you a clear account of why Marxism and the labor theory of value is incorrect, and can speak to your very specific concerns about worker power and class conflict in a way that gets across how modern social theorists and economists give a more compelling and ethically coherent account of the way the world works, and do so patiently and thoroughly.

Really this is: let's consider one possibility, that I am right and that you are extreme and wrong. Everything is going well, except for the radical weirdos trying to stop me from doing what I want.

Congratulations on being a vegan. 20% of the population doesn't have health insurance.

I'm no Marxist, but this regurgitation of neolib talking points is not being smart enough to refute a Marxist. The problem with today's "Marxists" is that they don't know enough to defend their own positions, and react with rage when the holes in their absurdly shallow knowledge gleaned from social media posts, Jacobin articles and hipster podcasts are confronted by simple, direct, good faith questions that they don't have answers to. It's not that people aren't well-studied enough to refute their extremism.

> Congratulations on being a vegan. 20% of the population doesn't have health insurance.

These two things are completely unrelated.