Comment by al_borland
1 day ago
I’ve found some success is small projects, with limited scope, in a greenfield.
I’m terrified to attempt agentic anything in the repo my job actually cares about. I triggered it once by accident, when the agent was first rolled out and enabled by default… it broke everything. Now I just use ask mode, and even that is wrong half the time, and once it goes wrong it just keeps getting worse.
I saw a post from Dave Plumber who vibe coded up a new cross platform task manager. He said his spec document for the AI was 107 pages long. So maybe what I’m doing wrong is not giving the AI a literal novel of spec.
> He said his spec document for the AI was 107 pages long.
This sounds like programming but with extra steps that make it take longer with less reliability.
Ikr, at that point the code itself is a better way of encoding the information.
I concur with your first sentence. I have found success creating some sort of MVP, but I have had virtually no success with taking something from initiation to completion.
My employer won't even provide LLMs for us, let alone allow us to use agentic coding on our repos. All our code is still USDA certified, organic, free-range code.
> He said his spec document for the AI was 107 pages long.
Absolutely not. My ADHD forbids such temptations of the dark arts. I'll feed any LLM a 107 page spec list, but I won't be writing nor reading that spec list.