← Back to context Comment by slopinthebag 1 day ago Where is the reasoning in linear regression? 15 comments slopinthebag Reply danielbln 1 day ago Where is the reasoning in synaptic transmission? necovek 1 day ago There isn't, which is exactly the point: we do not yet understand the fundamentals behind reasoning. anon48293 1 day ago Don’t we? We can build something which has all the output associated with reasoning.I’d say we’ve figured out the fundamentals behind reasoning. 7 replies → slopinthebag 16 hours ago This is just pure unbridled reductionism. "Show me a single atom in the human body that is 'alive'. You can't? Therefore we're all zombies...."Reasoning is an emergent property of complex systems. Prediction is not. Thus you cannot claim reasoning drives prediction. danielbln 16 hours ago Why can't an emergent capability arise in service of a predictive objective? 2 replies → koningrobot 18 hours ago "This much of x0, and this much of x1, and this much of x2, therefore it's that much of y"
danielbln 1 day ago Where is the reasoning in synaptic transmission? necovek 1 day ago There isn't, which is exactly the point: we do not yet understand the fundamentals behind reasoning. anon48293 1 day ago Don’t we? We can build something which has all the output associated with reasoning.I’d say we’ve figured out the fundamentals behind reasoning. 7 replies → slopinthebag 16 hours ago This is just pure unbridled reductionism. "Show me a single atom in the human body that is 'alive'. You can't? Therefore we're all zombies...."Reasoning is an emergent property of complex systems. Prediction is not. Thus you cannot claim reasoning drives prediction. danielbln 16 hours ago Why can't an emergent capability arise in service of a predictive objective? 2 replies →
necovek 1 day ago There isn't, which is exactly the point: we do not yet understand the fundamentals behind reasoning. anon48293 1 day ago Don’t we? We can build something which has all the output associated with reasoning.I’d say we’ve figured out the fundamentals behind reasoning. 7 replies →
anon48293 1 day ago Don’t we? We can build something which has all the output associated with reasoning.I’d say we’ve figured out the fundamentals behind reasoning. 7 replies →
slopinthebag 16 hours ago This is just pure unbridled reductionism. "Show me a single atom in the human body that is 'alive'. You can't? Therefore we're all zombies...."Reasoning is an emergent property of complex systems. Prediction is not. Thus you cannot claim reasoning drives prediction. danielbln 16 hours ago Why can't an emergent capability arise in service of a predictive objective? 2 replies →
danielbln 16 hours ago Why can't an emergent capability arise in service of a predictive objective? 2 replies →
koningrobot 18 hours ago "This much of x0, and this much of x1, and this much of x2, therefore it's that much of y"
Where is the reasoning in synaptic transmission?
There isn't, which is exactly the point: we do not yet understand the fundamentals behind reasoning.
Don’t we? We can build something which has all the output associated with reasoning.
I’d say we’ve figured out the fundamentals behind reasoning.
7 replies →
This is just pure unbridled reductionism. "Show me a single atom in the human body that is 'alive'. You can't? Therefore we're all zombies...."
Reasoning is an emergent property of complex systems. Prediction is not. Thus you cannot claim reasoning drives prediction.
Why can't an emergent capability arise in service of a predictive objective?
2 replies →
"This much of x0, and this much of x1, and this much of x2, therefore it's that much of y"