There's also always a "strictness" curve. Rust has specific rules where you could write something which doesn't break those rules but does break people who've done something very specific
At some point you reach the Hyrum's Law / Spacebar Heating edge where sure, there's no reasonable technical definition which concludes your change "broke" people but somebody's solution used to work and now it doesn't and they're angry about that.
To give an example that's only slightly less ridiculous than spacebar heating, maybe somebody depended on being able to parse a file from your library, you re-designed the library, there are no API changes but they're parsing your source code and now their approach doesn't work.
Generally, libraries with fewer and lighter users tend to be more lax, maybe they forgot to make a structure opaque, that's a break but none of their users notice, or they forgot to make an error type non-exhaustive, but everybody using their type had a default clause so no harm done when they add a new value.
Hyrum means that as you get bigger and more important, some day, the spacebar heating problem happens and too bad. A language (like Rust) can help you forestall that day somewhat, and reduce the blast radius when it does, but it is inevitable, Hyrum's law wasn't something you can outright prevent from happening, it's a factor for engineers to consider when designing systems, like misuse resistance.
Deprecating without breaking is fine in a minor version under semver.
There's also always a "strictness" curve. Rust has specific rules where you could write something which doesn't break those rules but does break people who've done something very specific
At some point you reach the Hyrum's Law / Spacebar Heating edge where sure, there's no reasonable technical definition which concludes your change "broke" people but somebody's solution used to work and now it doesn't and they're angry about that.
To give an example that's only slightly less ridiculous than spacebar heating, maybe somebody depended on being able to parse a file from your library, you re-designed the library, there are no API changes but they're parsing your source code and now their approach doesn't work.
Generally, libraries with fewer and lighter users tend to be more lax, maybe they forgot to make a structure opaque, that's a break but none of their users notice, or they forgot to make an error type non-exhaustive, but everybody using their type had a default clause so no harm done when they add a new value.
Hyrum means that as you get bigger and more important, some day, the spacebar heating problem happens and too bad. A language (like Rust) can help you forestall that day somewhat, and reduce the blast radius when it does, but it is inevitable, Hyrum's law wasn't something you can outright prevent from happening, it's a factor for engineers to consider when designing systems, like misuse resistance.
Yeah. Agreed.
Did you miss "remove or change features." ?
No, I was just making a narrower point about one aspect of the comment.