← Back to context

Comment by p1esk

9 hours ago

Could you tell the difference between a grandmaster and stockfish if playing them online? If not, why would you care which one you are playing against?

I think I'd care because the entity on the other side cares about the game in a similar way to me. It's not just the technical details of how the pieces move, it's a human interaction.

Of course you can. Stockfish plays very different compared to a human, and it never ever blunders or makes mistakes.

  • I’ve never played against a grandmaster, but I have a feeling that he/she would play very different compared to me and would never make mistakes I could notice. Though admittedly I’m not very good at chess.

    • I've played both. The GM plays tremendously differently than Stockfish.

      Engines - specifically heuristically-driven ones like Stockfish - don't play like a strong GM. They play engine-perfect chess, which isn't how a GM plays with any consistency.

      I'm only a decent amateur (1550 USCF) but when I lose to a titled player it's largely explainable in human terms how it happened.

    • Grandmasters absolutely make mistakes, and you could learn to notice them with a few months of guided practice.