← Back to context

Comment by gruez

15 hours ago

Just like people complaining about "phablets" a decade ago right? "more bulky than a phone, smaller than a tablet"?

Modern phones are all phablets and it sucks but it's the only format they offer. Smaller phones are nicer to hold and nicer to use for everyday tasks. My thumb can actually reach things. At least AI will no doubt reduce the need for pressing buttons.

Manufacturers want phones to be thin so the only way to fit in the battery life is for the whole phone to be larger. In case you didn't notice it's really really difficult to find a side on photo of the iPhone Duo closed. They don't want to show the thickness.

  • Note that every time a company comes up with a choice between a smaller phone and a larger phone (up to some limit when you get into phablet territory), the larger phone sells in much, much higher numbers. Apple themselves tried the Mini, it sold at best a few percent of how well the regular phones sell.

    While you, personally, might prefer smaller phones, and that's a perfectly valid preference, you are very much in the minority.

Phablets are still bad, and yes, I am aware that a lot of phones today are just phablets. Everyone uses them, doesn't mean they're not bad.

Did the “phablets” take over the world?

  • Uh, yes? The first widespread usage of the word "phablet" I can recall was regarding the HTC HD2, which had a whopping 4.3" display and some people were losing their minds saying nobody would want to carry that in their pockets.

  • The original "phablet" was the Samsung Galaxy Note, considered comically large. At 147mm x 83mm, it's about the same size as the iPhone 18 Pro (150mm x 72mm)

  • Yes, the note 3 was considered "phablet", and it's much smaller than even ip17 now.

    • The note 3 was 151.2 x 79.2 x 8.3 mm

      The iPhone 17 is 149.6 x 71.5 x 8 mm

      So no, the note 3 is bigger than the iPhone 17

      But, and this is probably what you meant, the iPhone 17 has a bigger screen. That's because recent phones got rid of the bezels, so they can fit more screen in the same body. That's why they have taller aspect ratios.

      1 reply →