← Back to context

Comment by cma

16 hours ago

The Machine Stops by E. M. Forester is basically this world.

I’ve never read it but I did look up the Wikipedia summary after your comment.

I don’t see the similarity? It’s a dystopia run by a maniacal computer and everyone is forced to live underground until the machine collapses for some reason?

  • Climate change and killer drones run amok on the surface doesn't actually seem that far fetched now.

  • > I don’t see the similarity? It’s a dystopia run by a maniacal computer and everyone is forced to live underground until the machine collapses for some reason?

    I read that same summary. The similarity is pretty clear: the first step was letting a machine take over all economic and intellectual functions, leaving humanity useless and dependent it.

    We're talking about taking that step too.

    • The question, of course, is why should it inevitably lead to that kind of world, rather than The Culture? Or, to give a more realistic and likely example, something like the Colligatarch from Alan Dean Foster's "The I Inside".