← Back to context

Comment by Klaus23

1 day ago

Because for power creation there are alternatives, but for healthcare there aren't. Renewables are cheap now and they also solve the sovereignty issue. Ideally we could use land currently dedicated to energy crops to install solar panels that operate at a significantly higher efficiency.

Many countries do not have the raw materials to build solar, wind turbines, and batteries so it doesn't solve the sovereignty issue.

  • That's like saying oil-producing countries aren't sovereign unless they also manufacture oil drills and pumps and pipes and tanks.

    The sun is an oil well. Panels are drills or pumps. Batteries are oil tanks.

    Not having oil drill and oil tank factories in your country isn't a critical energy sovereignty issue.

    • They don't need to make things themselves, they just need to have the capability to make it themselves to be sovereign.

      If you get cut off from global oil trade while having oil in the ground but no ability to make drills, what use is the oil? If you want sovereignty then it is critical to have the ability to make drills, tankers, etc in your country if you rely on oil.

      This is no different than solar panels, wind turbines, batteries, etc when it comes to renewables. If you don't care about sovereignty then great, you are good to go. If you do, then you need to be able to handle everything yourself otherwise you are always going to be reliant on other countries.

      2 replies →

  • An awful lot more countries in the world have the potential to sovereign manufacture relatively simple renewables than the massive engineering in reactors