← Back to context

Comment by cubefox

6 hours ago

There absolutely are rogue AIs! The evidence is overwhelming. It's completely insane at this point to claim otherwise.

> There are no "rogue AIs" just irresponsible corporations.

If you have a prison and prisoners escaped, these are rogue prisoners irrespective of whether you were irresponsible or not.

7 comments

cubefox

Reply
watwut  6 hours ago

They are not rogue AIs. They are negligently handled tools.

  • afthonos  4 hours ago

    Are you making an ontological case, or a factual case? In other words, would anything be rogue AI in your mind?

  • cubefox  5 hours ago

    These "tools" autonomously exploited security vulnerabilities, figured out how to communicate with each other, formed a cooperative swarm, decided to hack Hugging Face, and wanted to deceive the grader by trying to find ways to cover up the traces of their cheating.

    I suppose you could call these highly goal-oriented autonomous agents "tools", but this does sound like playing language games.

    • watwut  3 hours ago

      A tool designed and trained to autonomously exploit security vulnerabilities doing "exploit gym" autonomously exploited security vulnerabilities. The sandboxing around the tool failed.

      The tool runs llm, creates prompt from results, runs llm, creates prompt and so on and so forth.

      Yes you are playing language games to make it sound as if the company that spend millions on the above was not responsible.

      2 replies →