← Back to context

Comment by shevy-java

3 days ago

[flagged]

> A de-facto dictatorship.

It's a spectrum, not a binary. We're really far from the "packing bags and leaving the country" end where you're a slave to the state. America is nothing like an Iran or China where we have no power and no rights to overturn the state.

Let's see if any of these petty games helps Trump with midterms. I highly doubt it. Kalshi is already calling it a double win for Democrats.

The economic impact of the Iran War looks like it really cost Trump everything. And it's funny because he always campaigned on not getting into wars.

[flagged]

  • "the White House's legal challenge" is something they can certainly pursue, but they can't just ignore a judge's orders in the meantime.

    > Judges are not all-powerful dictators.

    No, but the three branches are (in theory) co-equal, which makes that also apply to said White House.

  • I was always taught that the executive branch enforces the law, not interprets it. If the executive branch or legislative branches disagree with the judicial branch, then they have the responsibility to appeal or deal with it; they can't just ignore it because they disagree.

    • It turns out that in the end, enforcement is the only thing that matters. Written law doesn't matter, and interpretation doesn't matter, except insofar as they affect enforcement.

  • It's incorrect in any case. The supreme court decreed him immune from prosecution (for "official acts", that is)

    • He is immune from prosecution. He can probably go stand in the press room door and get away with turning people away. His staffers are not.

  • Your argument is essentially that the Executive can ignore the Judicial branch, and the process of law, if they say they have a good reason.

    • Perhaps the next president will wave the magic executive order wand and reduce the age of eligibility for Medicare to zero. Or something else equally spicy and very progressive. Republicans used to understand that eventually the other side will win an election and do unto you everything you have done unto them, but apparently the current crop thinks they will be ruling forever.

      7 replies →