← Back to context

Comment by alexnewman

1 month ago

It truely amazes me how much smarter sceptical posters on hackernews are vs google, spacex , china and the whole space industry.

Maybe they figured out something us “normal” people haven’t, but the physics and economic challenges haven’t really been addressed, at all.

Suggesting such an idea without indicating how - and more importantly, why - you are going to do it makes it an article of faith.

Do I have faith in their trustworthiness? No. Do I think they want to do marketing for their AI financing? Yes!

  • I’ve worked for a few satellite companies. Nothing that Google or SpaceX suggested should be surprising.

Yeah.. remember people being skeptical about reusable self-landing rockets, until SpaceX proved them wrong? I would not put much trust in resident skeptics.

what is it exactly? jealousy i think. plus then add Elon hate. but now Google wants to do it too.

i mean why wouldn;t you want sci-fi things taking shape?