Comment by sarchertech
19 hours ago
That is a cool app. But if you’d said you’d made it by hand in a few months I would have believed you.
If I had a working software factory like you describe, I’d expect you to have hundreds of apps of that level of complexity in a year.
> I don't even know how "vibe-coding" works in a team environment, because for me now it feels like it's "ideas to app" directly, so dumping by brain/ideas directly into a functional product.
But you don’t have any users much less paying users, so you have no idea if this system works when you do.
Thanks!
> I’d expect you to have hundreds of apps of that level of complexity in a year.
I am working at around 7-8 projects at the same time. The limit becomes me having to remember what I was doing for each one. AI can implement things nicely, but it really sucks at deciding which features and having its own ideas about novel game mechanics or UI/UX patterns.
I don't consider it a "software factory", just a more robust way to implement features, and it's still a WIP. One system I implemented locally is called "TaskHub", which receives some implementation or testing details from a SoTA mosel like Astra and implements it locally using Qwen 3.8 27b running on a RTX 3090.
I delegate things like app testing, navigating the app and taking screenshots, analyzing screenshots, etc.
And yes, this specific app doesn't have any users yet, I will launch it next week after I finalize the user authentication, payment flows and mobile apps. I will release it mostly as is, see user response, and then change it accordingly.
>not a factory
> I don't even know how "vibe-coding" works in a team environment, because for me now it feels like it's "ideas to app" directly, so dumping by brain/ideas directly into a functional product.
If you have a system that does “ideas to app directly”, that certainly sounds like what people are talking about when they say software factory. In fact my very large company would probably pay you millions if you could come in and make this work for our applications.
Hmm, my phrasing was ambigous, I didn't mean it's one idea fo one fully functional app.
But more of, one feature idea, that the AI can add to an app.
So it's not prompting "a gamefied piano learning app", but adding a single new feature like "add a minigame, where the user can control a character on the musical staff, [... 20 paraphs later ... ], make a good implementation plan, implement and test the app until everything is production-ready and bug free /goal"
That is a single "idea" that also requires a lot of fine-tuning after, but rarely in terms of code, most of the times it's only in terms of functionality and design choices.