← Back to context

Comment by karmakaze

10 hours ago

I don't think it qualifies for this part:

> The communication must be made in a manner in which another person may view it.

Even 'transmitted' is too broad if you also consider iCloud backup to be a means.

How could it fail to qualify for that? Another person did view it, which clearly establishes that another person could have viewed it.

The clause in the law is pointless, since if you do something that nobody else can see, you can never be punished. But many, many, many laws are written without regard to whether they make any sense.