Comment by radford-neal

Not quite. If the statement is provable, an algorithm can find the proof by just looking at all possible proofs, in order of length. (It's assumed that that a valid proof can be algorithmically confirmed to be valid - there's an algorithm that when given a purported proof will eventually output "valid" if it is in fact valid.) The algorithm will find a proof eventually, if there is one. If there is a (provable) counterexample, the algorithm will similarly eventually find that. What Goedel's incompleteness theorem says is that such a search algorithm may never terminate - never finding a proof, and never finding a counterexample.

(The algorithms described above are of course completely impractical, taking time exponential in the length of the proof (of theorem or counterexample).)