← Back to context

Comment by ndriscoll

5 hours ago

Well, per another comment in the thread, some 20% of their solutions come with formalization, so there's a very high chance (probably higher than typical asks of research mathematics) that they did solve the problem. And that also presents a pretty easy solution to the scaling issue: demand formal proofs.

(If you're going to object that it's difficult to validate the statement of the problem, please first state your level of experience doing so. It's getting tiring seeing people raise this objection and claim that a statement is just as hard as a proof over and over who don't seem to actually know any math and have never tried to write anything in Lean)

Formalization only helps you if you prove that the formalization is correctly implemented, that the model didn’t subtly mess up or cheat.

Someone still has to read the formalization.