← Back to context

Comment by Dylan16807

9 hours ago

Except l has a specific meaning that isn't 1, while the entire purpose of ' and " is quoting (and apostrophe).

The equivalent of l for 1 is doing font-specific pseudo smart quotes with ` and '

" and ' are themselves conjoined with other uses.

" can be inches or arcseconds from cartography.

' can be feet (of measure) or arcminutes from cartography.

These actually all have slightly different symbols, and the symbols for the left/right quotation marks are actually farthest from this approximation, even if they are the most frequent usage.

It’s always been wrong in some respect to use a single available symbol to emulate three or more different typographical tasks, but quotation marks may actually be the one where the emulation is the most wrong.

  • Overstriking ' was commonly used (on typewriters and ASCII printers) for acute accents, and overstriking " was commonly used for a diaeresis. The glyphs used in typewriter fonts and traditional (pre-Unicode) Unix terminal fonts are compromises between these different uses.

That equivalency only holds if there is a visual distinction in the output between the l and the 1. There often wasn't when this practice was popular.