Comment by socializer
5 hours ago
> I think if there is a major change in code review culture, it's not going to happen first in established engineering teams. It'll happen in startups that adopt a no-human-review policy from jump and then maintain it as they mature.
I've been hearing this for more than a year. But if these startups are all moving at superhuman speed, a month instead of a year from idea to a shipping product, where are the products? Every time I ask that, people talk about the amazing velocity gains they experience for the thing they are about to ship. It never does, unless we count throwaway hobby projects at GitHub - by that metric, AI is adding a lot of software. And I guess never-downloaded slop-games on mobile app stores.
But if you actually go shopping for consumer or enterprise software that's camera-ready, the landscape is basically the same as in 2022.
It's as if building something was not a bottleneck for startups. Go figure.
Codex/CC and other OpenAI and Anthropic products like Dots, are examples of how quickly real products can be built today. But to me, they feel more like mediocre products bloated with feature slop. Nothing extraordinary or technologically innovative.
Pi.dev and Cursor's Tab completion are two of the most innovative and extraordinary products I know in AI era, and both were built by humans, at least in their "breakthrough" stages.
I want the boosters to address this head on - chime in?