Comment by verandaguy
1 day ago
It's a tool that promises that you can be lazy. That's, like, the whole schtick. Of course people will be lazy using it, even if they don't intend to.
And in much of the industry, using LLMs is regressing into what I've heard be jokingly called "yes engineering," where you give an LLM-generated plan the lightest of skims (if that) and just hit allow or yes with auto mode or whatever.
I don’t think that’s “the whole shtick” anymore than it is for something like cars. There are valid ways to use it as a tool to provide net new value, and inevitably a whole bunch of people will end up using it as a lazy machine anyway, especially if their country/society benefits from people using it that way (Americans in both cases).
This was literally George Jetson's job on The Jetsons: pushing a button on the computer RUDI while it did all the work. The joke being that he works 4 hours a day, 2 days a week pushing a button and complains about being tired when he gets home, because that's how the future will be: full of unimaginable leisure.
As alienating and stultifying as this work seemed, however, The Jetsons is still an optimistic future compared to the one we're getting: when George is fired, RUDI intervenes on his behalf and gets him rehired. I don't see Claude doing that for me; its raison d'être is ensuring I'm put out of work.
I use it as a hybrid of that I guess: I prompt some simple tool into existence, iterate a bit, then I look at the code, am very dismayed and spend more time than it might have taken me to build from scratch to refactor it.
It solves a huge motivation problem for me though, because having a working prototype of something I want is a lot. Especially when it's something I never did, where I cannot imagine the end result fully, or estimate my own ability to get there. But if I can see the thing in action, while I may look at the code (and my own skills) and realise it would take me months to make it something I could share with others, I at least know there is a destination.
Not to mention how it surfaces all sorts of issues I didn't think of, so I'm basically prototyping v2 before I ever fully built v1, and so on, until it kinda settles.
I guess I'm lucky I don't do it professionally :P