← Back to context

Comment by hn_throwaway_99

8 hours ago

> I think this and many other questionable UI decisions across the industry in recent years is the fallout of the old guard of UI designers having rotated out for younger replacements in the past decade with little transfer of knowledge occurring.

Not sure about that, given that John Gruber specifically lays the blame for a slew of recent shitty Apple design decisions on Alan Dye (cough liquid glass cough), and also the reversal of these shitty design decisions on changes made when Dye jumped ship for Meta. Gruber also says the Apple design team is much happier after Dye's departure.

Dye must be over 50, so I don't count him as a "younger replacement".

Dye comes from fashion and packaging not UI design. In that sense, he is a younger generation of UI designers.