← Back to context

Comment by afavour

17 hours ago

But the alternative is another monopolistic tech giant. There is no viable third platform. So I agree with OP, the answer is breaking them up.

Pixel phones have an unlocked bootloader. One can load GrapheneOS onto those phones without needing to jailbreak them.

Even without flashing a new OS, one can install third party app stores (e.g. F-Droid) with open source apps and/or side-load modified versions of those apps.

> There is no viable third platform.

There is no "viable third platform" because people don't vote against the two existing ones with their wallets.

Can you name an example where a government succeeded in breaking up a monopoly, and the result was better for consumers? AT&T, IBM, and Microsoft were all "broken up", but it didn't make a difference for consumers. In every case, a competitor forced them to change their ways.

  • Standard Oil.

    Also 2 of those 3 companies were famously NOT broken up.

    • I mean, breaking up Standard Oil wasn't exactly great for consumers either. And those companies eventually re-merged anyways. But ole Rockefeller sure did make out well due to the breakup.