← Back to context

Comment by pfdietz

12 hours ago

The cost of putting dirt in a pile is $1-2/ton.

so $36-72k for days of 1GW of power? Sounds pretty cheap to me ...

  • They also state the cost per kWh(th) of storage capacity is about $0.10, or $100,000/GWh(th). This is thermal energy, which is converted to work at maybe 40% efficiency, mind you. There are costs over and above the dirt (for example, pipes laid through the dirt to carry heat in/out).

The biggest expense will be the pipework inside that pile. That you won't be able to service easily. And you'll also need a LOT of insulation around it to prevent heat from leaking out too quickly.

  • Thermal storage benefits from the square/cube scaling, so the amount of insulation goes down as you scale up the storage.

  • The insulation is just more dirt.

    • Homework: compute the heat flux from a 40 meter radius sphere, given the surface temperature 600C and the ambient temperature 0C. Now compute the amount of insulation needed to keep its temperature above 500C for 3 months, given that dry sand has an R value of 0.25 W/mK.

      1 reply →