Voted with 11 MPs (députés) in favor and 10 MPs against. That's over a total of 577 MPs. This was clearly a garbage vote on a Friday morning just for kicks.
Now there will be a bit of news coverage, some opinion polls and the politics will assess if this is worth blaming tech giants for the current social unrest.
A (later?) English article: https://powerupgaming.co.uk/2026/10/31/what-frances-proposed... (My default expectation is terrible quality from sources I don't normally use, but this seems at least decent.) (The amendment explicitly mentions games as a sector with a lot of data relative to revenue.)
France is spiraling into a debt whirlpool needing to use debt to pay off debt, basically having no good way to resolve the issue without a lot of pain (“austerity”). Any politician with enough foresight to do what needs to be done gets removed, so those that remain are selected for their thick foreheads.
What’s more fun is that while france is teetering on the brink, it’s hardly alone, and it’s collapse will tip the dominoes.
Austerity is what got France in this mess in the first place + the Euro.
This movie has already happened in Greece.
Greece's former finance minister Yanis Varoufakis on the European economic policy during the Euro crisis:
"When I met Christine Lagarde for the first time — she was the managing director of the International Monetary Fund at the time, before she moved over to the presidency of the European Central Bank — she astounded me, because she was extremely sympathetic to my analysis of what had gone wrong and why the austerity programs could not work.
She said, “Of course, Yanis, they cannot work — you’re right.” She actually criticized me from a position to the left of my own thinking because she said that I was being too modest and too moderate in what I was demanding on behalf of my people.
However, she then added immediately, “But Yanis, you have to understand that we have put a lot of political capital into this program, and your career and mine both depend on going along with it.” "
On the Euro: “Look, we created the euro in a terrible way. The architecture was as if we had designed it in order to fail. It was clear from the very beginning. Think about it. We created a central bank for twenty countries. The central bank didn’t have a treasury, and there were twenty treasuries that didn’t have a central bank.”
They made a pension plan that relied on people having more kids and not getting jobs outsourced, then they didn't ahve kids and got outsourced.
Then there is the whole "they literally never decolonized out of africa" just to keep the economy going this long and that is unable to be exploited like in the past.
They cut the kid's programs to the bone and the kids told them in the most french way possible that that was bad. Inequality has been worse than 1789 for years now.
France has sky high taxes and yet they run a 5% deficit. Cant cut social programs that are way too generous (in relation to income) so higher taxes it is.
A massive portion of our lawmakers are absolute clowns too, it's not exclusive to the US.
Note that this amendment to the law was passed with 11 votes for, 10 no... With a national assembly of 577. I have to assume it was voted at night, that's when peak democracy happens.
> A cap on the tax is planned to take into account sectors with a high ratio of data emitted per euro of turnover, such as video on demand or video games.
I kept posting about it here over the years but at officially 57% of the GDP being public spending (and the actual percentage is bigger than that because a great many of the "private" companies that are monopolies are basically owned by state apparatchiks), France is already a planned economy.
And there's only one outcome for planned economies and its misery.
And when socialists succeed in establishing misery, they've guaranteed themselves an endless stream of voters. And they can only drive the country more into the ground. So more misery. So more socialism. So more planned economy.
France "offered" fiber optic to the entire country (at taxpayers' expense) and now that people have big Internet pipes, they're going to implement Bill Gates' old dream [1]: tax every single packet of information.
What's up with France is socialism. That's what up with France.
[1] in a leaked memo when the Internet began to take off, Bill Gates explained he wanted to tax every single network packet (for those who remember).
then why not have an annual "please help us keep the government running tax" and at least be honest? Why invent taxes on things that don't make sense?
A tax is usually applied to help facilitate maintenance for something you are using. Or to disincentivize "bad" behavior. For example i pay taxes in the US that directly help pay for public schools, the fire department, roads, etc.
How does the french government bear any cost if i download data from a data center? What bad behavior is disincentivezed with this tax?
So why dont we tax air? Everyone is breathing all the time, if the point of a Tax is to raise revenue we should be taxing every breath
Oh yeah you also have to not kill the population economically. What about the citizens who are doing large scale research on datasets? Those are the ones who are going to make billion dollar companies and they wont happen if they are watching the meter all the time because the government has decided to tax thought, so better not think too much!
Reading through an English translation of the article, it seems there is a cap?
> There is a cap so that services using a lot of bandwidth but earning slimmer margins are not crushed. The amount charged cannot exceed 15% of revenue earned in France, or 2% of worldwide revenue. Besides raising money, the authors present the tax as ...
How much does the VideoLan foundation make from France, as revenue?
Edit: I think I've figured it out. The hosting services would need to pay, and they get taxed based on their revenue, and they would probably pass the extra cost on to their consumers, which would include non-profits like the VideoLan foundation.
Is this then to counter tax avoidance by companies that conveniently transfer the profits out of the country? "Oh no we made a loss in France so no tax to pay in France because we had to pay our Irish subsidiary €1bn for digital services".
I don't know if this is one of those cases but governments are generally trying to figure out how to avoid such transfers away of tax revenue.
Is the cap the max of either? I assume so. 2% of global income tax would be absurd. Is this tax on data in France, I assume, not globally?
It feels absurd to punish data heavy companies. What a weird proxy disciminator. Makes so little sense.
Also though, perhaps we see YouTube and others not just adopting & making available but pushing AV2 much faster! "YouTube AV2 streams will be available for Web as soon as early 2027." And perhaps resolutions dropping precipitously too! http://aomedia.org/press%20releases/AOMedia-Rapid-AV2-Adopti...
> It feels absurd to punish data heavy companies. What a weird proxy disciminator. Makes so little sense.
This is part of the net-0 narrative and the degrowth movement that's been growing(no pun intended) in Europe. Nevermind that growth in the EU is already pretty low to begin with...
EU and European countries are rent-seeking apparatuses whose only purpose is ensuring the status quo. Italy attempted to tax free cloud storage offered by providers such as Google, etc. to customers along with their own paid storage -- private storage is also, of course, taxed on purchase, for all hardware: from 5 to 30€ depending on capacity and intended use, because the citizen is automatically presumed to store copyrighted material on them.
Wait until you hear about Germany, where you have to pay a fee on all data storage media because it's possible that you might use it to copy something. It's awesome.
Edit: I apologize to the French people. I did not intend to disrespect your innovations or appropriate your legislature.
Same in Poland. You pay tax on printers, printer paper, disc burners, writable discs and so on, and in return you may legally make backup copies of the copyrighted works and share them with your close relatives. IANAL, though.
The best part is that this year they've added smartphones, tablets and laptops to the list of taxed devices, which is ridiculous and pure greed. And the minister argued that the manufacturers will bear the increased cost themselves, which just adds insult to injury. She also said that other countries do that already (Germany was the example AFAIR, hehe), but she just conveniently left out the fact that Poland already has one of the highest VAT rates in the EU, so our devices will be even more expensive relative to their base price, than they already are.
The state, over time, becomes parasitic. This has always been the case.
Combined with universal suffrage and the welfare state to buy votes it is a recipe for decline and ruin.
The french state is bankrupt like all the other western democracies. They hide their pension obligations well, but that doesn’t change reality.
This system will continue to suck everything it can out of the young and the productive, because those are the incentives. There is no point at which it will stop, short of regime change.
You should look at government spending as a percentage of GDP instead of tax revenue. Certain governments like printing a lot of money and the effect of it isn't that different from taking that money in as taxes.
Also, I don't know if that is true in this case, but these numbers will often omit state taxes for the US and only like at federal taxes. Ie they leave the US looking better than it is.
The IMF puts the US at 37.92%, but France at 57.17%.
If you graph these values over the 20th century you should become quite worried. It turns out that a lot of our "good times" coincide with a slow but perpetual increase in this number. But this number will have to stop increasing at some point and we're reaching that point.
* Put another way, it is possible to grow out of debt. The US is the only member of the $40 trillion debt club, but is also the only member of the $32 trillion GDP club. Scott Bessent has been talking since before being named Treasury Secretary about 3/3/3. <https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/treasury-secretary-nomi...>
* Put yet another way, if you are so worried about the US, you should be sounding a five-alarm bell for France and Italy, and three alarms for most of the rest of the developed world.
The tax percentage is irrelevant without the context of what it pays for.
If you live in a country where you pay $400 in taxes but all healthcare is paid for by the government, you are better off than someone living in a country where they have to pay only $300 in taxes - but an additional $200 for private health insurance just to cover what you get for "free".
Is the quality and accessibility of healthcare in those countries equal? There are very few countries in which all healthcare is paid by the government and private insurance is banned. Most developed countries have a two-tier system where poor people with only the government health plan get reasonable access to essential healthcare services but often can't obtain more advanced treatments, or have to wait in long queues. Affluent people then pay for supplemental private insurance to obtain faster and higher quality services. Healthcare providers typically prioritize patients who have private insurance that pays higher rates.
I currently pay $0.005/GB for bandwidth, which works out to a similar amount in Euros. So this tax would constitute a tenfold cost increase to deliver data to France.
even if content providers are paying - it still inhibits consumption as content providers simply pass the cost to the consumer.
imagine netflix vs megaupload. megaupload or any of those or torrents - they could be registered entities or none but they r not gonna pay. consumers will simply get their content from those sites vs the official ones.
show me the incentives and I will show you the outcome as charlie munger said.
The worst part of this is that now everybody who writes comments on Hacker News will violently insist that every company and individual in the world has to pay this tax and that you'll be in big trouble if you don't.
I've already had enough endless discussions with people saying that the US government will jail and fine US individuals on the behalf of France and Germany if they don't put cookie banners on their websites...
In what sense is the internet not P2P already? If we manage to establish a signal between us, we can definitely make an internet connection without any third party.
Huge asymmetries both in bandwidth and capability between up and downstream. A lot of US users are still on DOCSIS, a lot of users worldwide behind CGNAT (less of an issue with IPv6), stateful firewalls for cellular to avoid creating unsolicited radio traffic. A ton of the bandwidth the average person is consuming is from talking to a caching box sitting in the ISP's DC. Basically the network you're connected to is optimized for feeding you lots of data and having you send back ACKs.
Far too many people don't realise this. The internet only isn't P2P because of market economies of scale - like how all the bitcoins are (were) in Binance. The underlying tech is still P2P.
There is going to be a problem with everyone trying to register an address block. The internet addressing scheme isn't designed for many tiny networks and you'd have to use sub-blocks of a big block, but then someone owns the big block and gets held liable for the use of the whole block and therefore for the whole P2P system.
the underlying tech of the internet is of course P2P but there's little out there that allows us to actually establish a direct signal between us without needing to go through a bunch of centralized intermediary services. bitchat is one of the few that actually kind of manages it
This sounds ridiculous. What’s the point of such a high tax on a productivity-increasing service? Why tax specific things unless you want to discourage their use?
Does the French state believe that its sole purpose is to extract money from any possible source for the sake of it?
The average French retiree makes more money annually than the average French worker (who is the one paying the retiree). Any attempts to reduce the number or benefits of the former is met with riots. The French state represents the will of the French people, which in the limit, has a single luxury French bag salesman selling to a single rich tourist a bag for $400 b which is then used to pay for that years pensions.
The sole purpose of the French state is to delay the pension time bomb however possible so someone else is in charge and held accountable when it goes off.
As I understand it's mostly because it doesn't matter. It's not a standalone law, it's an amendment to the budget. Budget that has close to 0 chance to pass.
I believe they did the same thing last year. Everyone did their own pet amendments, claimed victories. And then when it was time to vote for the budget with all the amendments, the assembly unanimously voted against, scraping the whole thing.
Thank you for sharing. I saw some outrage discussions on social media concerning this, and it's unfortunate how far people are willing to spin this to feed their narrative.
I mean, I always try to see things through another point of view, but 0.055 euros per GB is just crazy. GTA is estimated to be 210GB, so to download it 1 time it would cost you 11 EUR, that's more than 10% the price of the product. Politicians are completely drifting apart from reality
On the other hand, it may ensure game editors start optimizing their assets. I'm pretty sure you can optimize those 210GB into 21GB just by deleting unused files.
If you're paying €35/month for home internet, consuming 500 GB per month, all of which was from taxable sources, and the tax was indirectly passed on to you, you'd be paying €60/month for internet.
But at the same time the tax is capped at 15% of the providing company's French revenue or 2% of its worldwide revenue, and realistically speaking, not all companies would pass the tax on to the users, so it could end up being a noticeable but not catastrophic additional expense for both users and companies, if the bill passes at all, that is.
Seems like it massively advantages domestic French companies. If they only operate in France, they pay 2%, while YouTube pays 15%. I imagine there could be games played where a French only subsidiary pays 2% of their global income, or maybe someone sets up a French only CDN that pays the tax.
How are they going to meter the traffic? Trust Netflix to report the numbers? (Pinky promise this is the true number;-)) Or request French ISP to monitor and analyze the traffic to know what went to which server?
Uh, I didn't see that coming. 8Gbps is deployed on most of the territory, that's potentially 5.5 cents/s, or about 200€/hour. Probably 1 or 2 orders of magnitude too high to be painless.
Given that the content providers (CDNs) are targeted, that would incentivize p2p. P2P networks are already employed by Microsoft to distribute updates, for instance.
What about CDNs? The article mention Valve, but their traffic comes from Akamai.
In any case, I would be surprised if this law ends up being adopted.
> I would be surprised if this law ends up being adopted.
It doesnt really matter. The damage is already done.
Macron tried to turn France (unsuccessfully one might say) into a country that is open to tech businesses. This law amongst other things (record tax rates, record deficit, weak economic growth, political instability, riots and much more) is simply another signal that opening a business in France today is just too risky and this will impact future growth for sure.
You have countries that look to the future and invest in it and then you have France.
I agree with most of what you said, but just want to point out that "riots" is much dramatized and overblown by the media. for what was mostly peaceful demonstrations, with a few nefarious actors (thieves, vandals, etc) using the chaos as cover, and in practice not much happened.
Now, in my opinon, the major issue with opening a business (regardless of the country) is that it is costly to do so, even if there are tax and state incentives. It's much easier to create a startup when seed funding is available.
This will not help enough to prevent France from being crushed by their debt. This is the beginning of the end for the eurozone. Bookmark this post for later reference.
I asked Claude for some context and while I'm hesitant to simply parrot its claims, they seem reasonable:
This passed late at night with an 11 to 10 vote (the entire assembly is 577 people). Odd amendments like this apparently pass somewhat frequently in similar ways.
Even though it passed, it's likely to be killed by the more right-wing parties when it gets to the senate.
I’m French and left wing. I utterly hate these clowns. Well-meaning people with good intentions and zero subject matter expertise. This is going to achieve either misery, or nothing.
apologies for the article in French, but I found no English sources reporting this yet. It is totally ridiculous...
Voted with 11 MPs (députés) in favor and 10 MPs against. That's over a total of 577 MPs. This was clearly a garbage vote on a Friday morning just for kicks.
Now there will be a bit of news coverage, some opinion polls and the politics will assess if this is worth blaming tech giants for the current social unrest.
That's strange. Here in Argentina at least half of the MP must be present[1] to get a valid vote and send it to the senate.
[1] Actually, seated in their seats! There is a detector and if they are standing they don't count as present.
2 replies →
The positive part is that this proposal has no chance of passing the senate at least
A (later?) English article: https://powerupgaming.co.uk/2026/10/31/what-frances-proposed... (My default expectation is terrible quality from sources I don't normally use, but this seems at least decent.) (The amendment explicitly mentions games as a sector with a lot of data relative to revenue.)
C'est d'un ridicule exquis.
So for a download of the newest Call of Duty, you'd need to pay 6.33 EUR? Not for the purchase but the download? What is up with France?
France is spiraling into a debt whirlpool needing to use debt to pay off debt, basically having no good way to resolve the issue without a lot of pain (“austerity”). Any politician with enough foresight to do what needs to be done gets removed, so those that remain are selected for their thick foreheads.
What’s more fun is that while france is teetering on the brink, it’s hardly alone, and it’s collapse will tip the dominoes.
Something to look forward to, I guess.
Austerity is not the answer.
Austerity is what got France in this mess in the first place + the Euro.
This movie has already happened in Greece.
Greece's former finance minister Yanis Varoufakis on the European economic policy during the Euro crisis:
"When I met Christine Lagarde for the first time — she was the managing director of the International Monetary Fund at the time, before she moved over to the presidency of the European Central Bank — she astounded me, because she was extremely sympathetic to my analysis of what had gone wrong and why the austerity programs could not work.
She said, “Of course, Yanis, they cannot work — you’re right.” She actually criticized me from a position to the left of my own thinking because she said that I was being too modest and too moderate in what I was demanding on behalf of my people.
However, she then added immediately, “But Yanis, you have to understand that we have put a lot of political capital into this program, and your career and mine both depend on going along with it.” "
On the Euro: “Look, we created the euro in a terrible way. The architecture was as if we had designed it in order to fail. It was clear from the very beginning. Think about it. We created a central bank for twenty countries. The central bank didn’t have a treasury, and there were twenty treasuries that didn’t have a central bank.”
https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2025/07/12/jacobins-on-the-le...
It's quite possible the fiscal situation of France will lead to the destruction of the eurozone if they leave.
2 replies →
> What’s more fun is that while france is teetering on the brink, it’s hardly alone, and it’s collapse will tip the dominoes.
California, for example.
2 replies →
So Europe is about to collapse?
9 replies →
They made a pension plan that relied on people having more kids and not getting jobs outsourced, then they didn't ahve kids and got outsourced.
Then there is the whole "they literally never decolonized out of africa" just to keep the economy going this long and that is unable to be exploited like in the past.
They cut the kid's programs to the bone and the kids told them in the most french way possible that that was bad. Inequality has been worse than 1789 for years now.
France has sky high taxes and yet they run a 5% deficit. Cant cut social programs that are way too generous (in relation to income) so higher taxes it is.
Dont see that working in the long run
10 replies →
A massive portion of our lawmakers are absolute clowns too, it's not exclusive to the US.
Note that this amendment to the law was passed with 11 votes for, 10 no... With a national assembly of 577. I have to assume it was voted at night, that's when peak democracy happens.
That doesn't seem like a quorum. Is there no quorum requirement for votes in the French Assembly?
Votes like that are, imo, entirely against the idea of a (representative) democracy. I wouldn't mind if votes like that were itself illegal.
1 reply →
It’s not uncommon to be vocal about the parties’ vote intent beforehand and coordinate so all 577 don’t have to show up for every single vote.
1 reply →
The amendment says:
> A cap on the tax is planned to take into account sectors with a high ratio of data emitted per euro of turnover, such as video on demand or video games.
https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/dyn/17/amendements/3210A/...
It would only be half a eurocent to update Firefox, though.
I don't see the appeal of these modern games.
> What is up with France?
I kept posting about it here over the years but at officially 57% of the GDP being public spending (and the actual percentage is bigger than that because a great many of the "private" companies that are monopolies are basically owned by state apparatchiks), France is already a planned economy.
And there's only one outcome for planned economies and its misery.
And when socialists succeed in establishing misery, they've guaranteed themselves an endless stream of voters. And they can only drive the country more into the ground. So more misery. So more socialism. So more planned economy.
France "offered" fiber optic to the entire country (at taxpayers' expense) and now that people have big Internet pipes, they're going to implement Bill Gates' old dream [1]: tax every single packet of information.
What's up with France is socialism. That's what up with France.
[1] in a leaked memo when the Internet began to take off, Bill Gates explained he wanted to tax every single network packet (for those who remember).
Why not? The point of a tax is to raise revenue
then why not have an annual "please help us keep the government running tax" and at least be honest? Why invent taxes on things that don't make sense?
A tax is usually applied to help facilitate maintenance for something you are using. Or to disincentivize "bad" behavior. For example i pay taxes in the US that directly help pay for public schools, the fire department, roads, etc.
How does the french government bear any cost if i download data from a data center? What bad behavior is disincentivezed with this tax?
1 reply →
Gotta make sure those pensioners are raking in more money per year than the people actually in their prime working years take home...
So why dont we tax air? Everyone is breathing all the time, if the point of a Tax is to raise revenue we should be taxing every breath
Oh yeah you also have to not kill the population economically. What about the citizens who are doing large scale research on datasets? Those are the ones who are going to make billion dollar companies and they wont happen if they are watching the meter all the time because the government has decided to tax thought, so better not think too much!
1 reply →
Which side of the Laffer Curve are they on?
It’s about to kill VideoLan foundation (VLC):
https://x.com/videolan/status/2116229135919919278?a=5Ua5pSOr...
Reading through an English translation of the article, it seems there is a cap?
> There is a cap so that services using a lot of bandwidth but earning slimmer margins are not crushed. The amount charged cannot exceed 15% of revenue earned in France, or 2% of worldwide revenue. Besides raising money, the authors present the tax as ...
How much does the VideoLan foundation make from France, as revenue?
Edit: I think I've figured it out. The hosting services would need to pay, and they get taxed based on their revenue, and they would probably pass the extra cost on to their consumers, which would include non-profits like the VideoLan foundation.
I don't understand why this law would directly affect VLC. As far as I understand they provide the software, not the content. Can someone explain?
People downloading their software.
get.videolan.org
3 replies →
From another comment here somewhere I understand that it is the content provider who is paying the tax, not the receiver.
3 replies →
I wouldn't "kill" anyone though right? They just block French IPs and forget about it?
AFAIK VLC is developed in France so they may hesitate to block their own country.
1 reply →
They can migrate to a non-France server in no time.
From the translation; to be paid by the content providers, with a cap of 15% of their income in France or 2% of their global income.
Dear Netflix, my startup is Uber but for carrier pigeons. Carrying SD cards! With AI-optimized routing because I gotta mention AI somewhere...
Is this then to counter tax avoidance by companies that conveniently transfer the profits out of the country? "Oh no we made a loss in France so no tax to pay in France because we had to pay our Irish subsidiary €1bn for digital services".
I don't know if this is one of those cases but governments are generally trying to figure out how to avoid such transfers away of tax revenue.
i doubt it.
that could be done directly by taxing IP licensing directly
> From the translation; to be paid by the content providers
Does anyone really believe that said content providers won't pass this to their customers?
The joke of this law is that it further advantages pirates, who don't have to pay this tax.
Is the cap the max of either? I assume so. 2% of global income tax would be absurd. Is this tax on data in France, I assume, not globally?
It feels absurd to punish data heavy companies. What a weird proxy disciminator. Makes so little sense.
Also though, perhaps we see YouTube and others not just adopting & making available but pushing AV2 much faster! "YouTube AV2 streams will be available for Web as soon as early 2027." And perhaps resolutions dropping precipitously too! http://aomedia.org/press%20releases/AOMedia-Rapid-AV2-Adopti...
> It feels absurd to punish data heavy companies. What a weird proxy disciminator. Makes so little sense.
This is part of the net-0 narrative and the degrowth movement that's been growing(no pun intended) in Europe. Nevermind that growth in the EU is already pretty low to begin with...
3 replies →
Avian Intelligence is the next frontier.
Can they avoid this tax by moving their servers to a neighbouring country?
EU and European countries are rent-seeking apparatuses whose only purpose is ensuring the status quo. Italy attempted to tax free cloud storage offered by providers such as Google, etc. to customers along with their own paid storage -- private storage is also, of course, taxed on purchase, for all hardware: from 5 to 30€ depending on capacity and intended use, because the citizen is automatically presumed to store copyrighted material on them.
Wait until you hear about Germany, where you have to pay a fee on all data storage media because it's possible that you might use it to copy something. It's awesome.
Edit: I apologize to the French people. I did not intend to disrespect your innovations or appropriate your legislature.
Same in Poland. You pay tax on printers, printer paper, disc burners, writable discs and so on, and in return you may legally make backup copies of the copyrighted works and share them with your close relatives. IANAL, though.
The best part is that this year they've added smartphones, tablets and laptops to the list of taxed devices, which is ridiculous and pure greed. And the minister argued that the manufacturers will bear the increased cost themselves, which just adds insult to injury. She also said that other countries do that already (Germany was the example AFAIR, hehe), but she just conveniently left out the fact that Poland already has one of the highest VAT rates in the EU, so our devices will be even more expensive relative to their base price, than they already are.
Hey we have the same in France! Always up with the good ideas.
Portugal has a similar law. As ridiculous as it gets.
Yeah, France still has that in 2026....
But France has that too...
The state, over time, becomes parasitic. This has always been the case.
Combined with universal suffrage and the welfare state to buy votes it is a recipe for decline and ruin.
The french state is bankrupt like all the other western democracies. They hide their pension obligations well, but that doesn’t change reality.
This system will continue to suck everything it can out of the young and the productive, because those are the incentives. There is no point at which it will stop, short of regime change.
Are you opposed to universal suffrage? What alternative do you have in mind?
2 replies →
Context: French taxes are 43.5% of GDP in 2024, the second highest among OECD countries. <https://taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/oecd-taxes-share-gdp> US is 25.6%; Germany is 38%; Britain is 34.4%.
You should look at government spending as a percentage of GDP instead of tax revenue. Certain governments like printing a lot of money and the effect of it isn't that different from taking that money in as taxes.
Also, I don't know if that is true in this case, but these numbers will often omit state taxes for the US and only like at federal taxes. Ie they leave the US looking better than it is.
https://www.imf.org/external/datamapper/exp@FPP/USA/FRA/JPN/...
The IMF puts the US at 37.92%, but France at 57.17%.
If you graph these values over the 20th century you should become quite worried. It turns out that a lot of our "good times" coincide with a slow but perpetual increase in this number. But this number will have to stop increasing at some point and we're reaching that point.
> Also, I don't know if that is true in this case, but these numbers will often omit state taxes for the US and only like at federal taxes.
From the article:
>Total tax revenues (federal, state, and local) as a percentage of GDP for OECD countries.
>If you graph these values over the 20th century you should become quite worried.
I agree that US debt is a real issue. But:
* The data indicates that, if necessary, the US has a (lot) more room to raise taxes.
* US GDP grew by 3.4% <https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/29/business/economy/us-econo...> in 3Q2026, beating estimates. French GDP shrank by 0.1% <https://www.france24.com/en/business/20261030-french-economy...> in 3Q2026, worse than estimates.
* Put another way, it is possible to grow out of debt. The US is the only member of the $40 trillion debt club, but is also the only member of the $32 trillion GDP club. Scott Bessent has been talking since before being named Treasury Secretary about 3/3/3. <https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/treasury-secretary-nomi...>
* Put yet another way, if you are so worried about the US, you should be sounding a five-alarm bell for France and Italy, and three alarms for most of the rest of the developed world.
1 reply →
The tax percentage is irrelevant without the context of what it pays for.
If you live in a country where you pay $400 in taxes but all healthcare is paid for by the government, you are better off than someone living in a country where they have to pay only $300 in taxes - but an additional $200 for private health insurance just to cover what you get for "free".
Is the quality and accessibility of healthcare in those countries equal? There are very few countries in which all healthcare is paid by the government and private insurance is banned. Most developed countries have a two-tier system where poor people with only the government health plan get reasonable access to essential healthcare services but often can't obtain more advanced treatments, or have to wait in long queues. Affluent people then pay for supplemental private insurance to obtain faster and higher quality services. Healthcare providers typically prioritize patients who have private insurance that pays higher rates.
This is taxing communication and should not be legal. I don't see how it's different from having to pay for talking to your neighbor.
You also pay taxes on your phone bill, and on stamps, and on the paper you use to write letters.
You also already pay sales tax on your internet service, but that's not what we're discussing here
1 reply →
Please tax talking to my neighbour - they won't stop talking!
I currently pay $0.005/GB for bandwidth, which works out to a similar amount in Euros. So this tax would constitute a tenfold cost increase to deliver data to France.
piracy wins again.
even if content providers are paying - it still inhibits consumption as content providers simply pass the cost to the consumer.
imagine netflix vs megaupload. megaupload or any of those or torrents - they could be registered entities or none but they r not gonna pay. consumers will simply get their content from those sites vs the official ones.
show me the incentives and I will show you the outcome as charlie munger said.
Obviously this is bonkers even for the French but just note that this can still be dropped by the senate.
Not saying that this is not a stupid law nonetheless.
If this is real, this is ridiculous. This would make most internet businesses even more unaccessible
The worst part of this is that now everybody who writes comments on Hacker News will violently insist that every company and individual in the world has to pay this tax and that you'll be in big trouble if you don't.
I've already had enough endless discussions with people saying that the US government will jail and fine US individuals on the behalf of France and Germany if they don't put cookie banners on their websites...
We really need to start building out a fully P2P internet.
In what sense is the internet not P2P already? If we manage to establish a signal between us, we can definitely make an internet connection without any third party.
Huge asymmetries both in bandwidth and capability between up and downstream. A lot of US users are still on DOCSIS, a lot of users worldwide behind CGNAT (less of an issue with IPv6), stateful firewalls for cellular to avoid creating unsolicited radio traffic. A ton of the bandwidth the average person is consuming is from talking to a caching box sitting in the ISP's DC. Basically the network you're connected to is optimized for feeding you lots of data and having you send back ACKs.
3 replies →
Far too many people don't realise this. The internet only isn't P2P because of market economies of scale - like how all the bitcoins are (were) in Binance. The underlying tech is still P2P.
There is going to be a problem with everyone trying to register an address block. The internet addressing scheme isn't designed for many tiny networks and you'd have to use sub-blocks of a big block, but then someone owns the big block and gets held liable for the use of the whole block and therefore for the whole P2P system.
2 replies →
the underlying tech of the internet is of course P2P but there's little out there that allows us to actually establish a direct signal between us without needing to go through a bunch of centralized intermediary services. bitchat is one of the few that actually kind of manages it
Reticulum (for multi medium) and Tor onion sites (for private hosting over legacy IP) and you’re already there.
This sounds ridiculous. What’s the point of such a high tax on a productivity-increasing service? Why tax specific things unless you want to discourage their use?
Does the French state believe that its sole purpose is to extract money from any possible source for the sake of it?
>Does the French state believe that its sole purpose is to extract money from any possible source for the sake of it?
Yes. French taxes are 43.5% of GDP in 2024, the second highest among OECD countries. <https://taxpolicycenter.org/statistics/oecd-taxes-share-gdp> US is 25.6%; Germany is 38%; Britain is 34.4%; Canada is 34.9%.
The average French retiree makes more money annually than the average French worker (who is the one paying the retiree). Any attempts to reduce the number or benefits of the former is met with riots. The French state represents the will of the French people, which in the limit, has a single luxury French bag salesman selling to a single rich tourist a bag for $400 b which is then used to pay for that years pensions.
The sole purpose of the French state is to delay the pension time bomb however possible so someone else is in charge and held accountable when it goes off.
What's the 11-10 vote? DId everybody go on holidays and leave only 21 members in session?
As I understand it's mostly because it doesn't matter. It's not a standalone law, it's an amendment to the budget. Budget that has close to 0 chance to pass.
I believe they did the same thing last year. Everyone did their own pet amendments, claimed victories. And then when it was time to vote for the budget with all the amendments, the assembly unanimously voted against, scraping the whole thing.
Sounds like you're saying this tax didn't actually pass and won't, and this whole thing is overblown.
Thank you for sharing. I saw some outrage discussions on social media concerning this, and it's unfortunate how far people are willing to spin this to feed their narrative.
Thanks, this should be the top comment. I think literally no-one in this thread bothered to translate or read the article lol.
I mean, I always try to see things through another point of view, but 0.055 euros per GB is just crazy. GTA is estimated to be 210GB, so to download it 1 time it would cost you 11 EUR, that's more than 10% the price of the product. Politicians are completely drifting apart from reality
By the way, why on Earth is GTA 210GB? That's insane.
Textures, voice acting, music, 3d models. Probably in that order.
On the other hand, it may ensure game editors start optimizing their assets. I'm pretty sure you can optimize those 210GB into 21GB just by deleting unused files.
If you're paying €35/month for home internet, consuming 500 GB per month, all of which was from taxable sources, and the tax was indirectly passed on to you, you'd be paying €60/month for internet.
But at the same time the tax is capped at 15% of the providing company's French revenue or 2% of its worldwide revenue, and realistically speaking, not all companies would pass the tax on to the users, so it could end up being a noticeable but not catastrophic additional expense for both users and companies, if the bill passes at all, that is.
11 votes to 10… there was basically no one to vote for. Stop wasting your time on that, it’s going to get removed next time.
Seems like it massively advantages domestic French companies. If they only operate in France, they pay 2%, while YouTube pays 15%. I imagine there could be games played where a French only subsidiary pays 2% of their global income, or maybe someone sets up a French only CDN that pays the tax.
How are they going to meter the traffic? Trust Netflix to report the numbers? (Pinky promise this is the true number;-)) Or request French ISP to monitor and analyze the traffic to know what went to which server?
They do request ISPs to monitor and report, yes.
Uh, I didn't see that coming. 8Gbps is deployed on most of the territory, that's potentially 5.5 cents/s, or about 200€/hour. Probably 1 or 2 orders of magnitude too high to be painless.
Given that the content providers (CDNs) are targeted, that would incentivize p2p. P2P networks are already employed by Microsoft to distribute updates, for instance.
What about CDNs? The article mention Valve, but their traffic comes from Akamai.
In any case, I would be surprised if this law ends up being adopted.
> I would be surprised if this law ends up being adopted.
It doesnt really matter. The damage is already done.
Macron tried to turn France (unsuccessfully one might say) into a country that is open to tech businesses. This law amongst other things (record tax rates, record deficit, weak economic growth, political instability, riots and much more) is simply another signal that opening a business in France today is just too risky and this will impact future growth for sure.
You have countries that look to the future and invest in it and then you have France.
I agree with most of what you said, but just want to point out that "riots" is much dramatized and overblown by the media. for what was mostly peaceful demonstrations, with a few nefarious actors (thieves, vandals, etc) using the chaos as cover, and in practice not much happened.
Now, in my opinon, the major issue with opening a business (regardless of the country) is that it is costly to do so, even if there are tax and state incentives. It's much easier to create a startup when seed funding is available.
1 reply →
This will not help enough to prevent France from being crushed by their debt. This is the beginning of the end for the eurozone. Bookmark this post for later reference.
As if France doesn’t need even more ways to regulate itself into global irrelevance.
Maybe focus on the riots in the streets and sort that out vs wasting energy on nonsense like this. Just saying.
They want to tax hyperscalers and streaming services, but you have to do it via side channels to not directly confront the US.
as these costs usually end up with the consumer, this would effectively tripple my internet bill. so it's a 66% tax
France is URSS without yuri gagarin. Save us from this crazyness of socialite hellhole
That's an exorbitant amount per GB.
I guess at least it's capped somewhat? Is there more background preceding this legislation?
This seems as ridiculous as having 1TB internet caps for residential ISPs in 2026.
its capped to 15% of revenue (not profit) in France, which is laughable...
ok, so if i want to just update the game i already paid, i need to pay again?
This can only be overturned later - makes no sense
Hurray, a new form of regressive taxation.
The upside might be the return of CDs?
Yeah there's going to be a whole USB flash drive economy like in Cuba
And how many CDs is the 210GB mention above for GTA ?
Putting aside whether this is a good idea or not, this rate is like 1,000%. The tax is 10x more than bandwidth itself costs.
Everyone hates the socialist party, episode 3825. It's okay, they're soon just a part of history and the left will be better off without them.
The French state might as well not exist anymore at this point. It's like the last breaths of a dying man
If you are looking for the silliest legislations worldwide you can save time by just looking at France
When we say best in the world at everything, we mean everything (⌐■_■)
That said, we do have the Germans as neighbours who are pretty damn skilled too.
Indiana says hold my beer....
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_pi_bill
I asked Claude for some context and while I'm hesitant to simply parrot its claims, they seem reasonable:
This passed late at night with an 11 to 10 vote (the entire assembly is 577 people). Odd amendments like this apparently pass somewhat frequently in similar ways.
Even though it passed, it's likely to be killed by the more right-wing parties when it gets to the senate.
If not stopped, these commies will have us all wearing a fart monitor and taxing us per fart.
why not tax ai instead?
I’m French and left wing. I utterly hate these clowns. Well-meaning people with good intentions and zero subject matter expertise. This is going to achieve either misery, or nothing.
Everyone is left in france beside the minority of people having a job and being net redistributor of wealth to a massive unemployed privileged caste
That’s hyperbolic and not representative of reality
1 reply →
The socialist party hasn't been well-meaning people for a while. I wouldn't even consider them left. Otherwise agree.
Fair. I’m not even sure what they stand for these days. Either way it’s not working