← Back to context

Comment by Malloffe

18 days ago

Voted with 11 MPs (députés) in favor and 10 MPs against. That's over a total of 577 MPs. This was clearly a garbage vote on a Friday morning just for kicks.

Now there will be a bit of news coverage, some opinion polls and the politics will assess if this is worth blaming tech giants for the current social unrest.

That's strange. Here in Argentina at least half of the MP must be present[1] to get a valid vote and send it to the senate.

[1] Actually, seated in their seats! There is a detector and if they are standing they don't count as present.

  • It's baffling how it isn't 100% present, since any law once passed will affect 100% of the population. It isn't like a law only applies to jurisdictions where the MPs were present for the vote.

    • One of them can have a very bad diarrhea, or go to the UN meeting to protect baby seals or something.

      Here we require 50%+ present and to partially approve the law 50%+ of the present. So sniping correctly, a 25% is enough.

      There is a weird iteration, when on party ensure 49% of the total of positive votes. Sometimes they have a dubious 3% of the votes of abstention from other parties that is a shame/hidden way to vote in favor. The 48% MP of the other party hide nearby while there is only 49% present, but if the 3% appear then they must rush in and vote against.

      49% yes --> not aproved

      49% yes + 3% abstention --> aproved

      49% yes + 3% abstention + 48% no --> not aproved

      I'd prefer 50%+ of the total for everything. (Note that 50% is required for some special topics, so it's not ridiculous to ask it for everything.)