← Back to context

Comment by drweevil

11 days ago

People in the US have a sense that the economy is rigged against them. (Just try to obtain health insurance, for example. Go ahead, it's open-enrollment season right now!) AI has become the poster child of this inequity. From the perspective of the average person, AI is all downsides, with no upsides:

AI will replace you in the workplace. So say the AI bros themselves!

AI will transfer wealth from the poor to the wealthy. See above.

AI will bring on the apocalypse! Again, according to the AI bros.

AI infrastructure takes land and other resources away from other uses (food, e.g.), pollutes the environment non-AI beneficiaries live in, raises our energy costs. Worse, the data center issue has demonstrated the undemocratic nature of our AI "policy", such as it is. People being arrested at public hearings for expressing dissenting views, and even body-slammed, is not a good look. In WV, where I live, the ability to regulate data center siting has been taken away from local communities altogether. Again, not a good look for democracy.

So, what makes all this worthwhile and worthy of support? Anything? Winning the "AI war" with China? Why is this important?

Taking the human out of human experience simply is not appealing nor is it worth the huge societal cost Sam Altman says we should pay for this technology.