← Back to context

Comment by Y-bar

9 days ago

”Rewrite in Rust” fanboys are more annoying than crypto bros. How is such a feat even possible?

I dunno,unlike the crypto/NFT era, Rust rewrites have demonstrated measured performance and memory savings gains. Some grimace when they see "written in Rust" as a tagline but my immediate thought tends to land more on the "thank God this isn't an electron app" side of things

  • Operative word is “fanboys”, I have mostly no qualms of actual rewrites to that language. It’s the fanboys who insist upon injecting themselves and their opinions everywhere with net negative impact.

  • You're comparing the rust rewrite of a web-based desktop application with the rust rewrite of a compiler+interpreter/jit. The former improves things by removing 12 layers of abstraction and an entire browser engine. The latter, not so much, it's already bare-metal.

    So as much as people on this forum love to shit on it, PHP is already very fast and memory efficient.

    The gains from the ongoing rust rewrite are (in order):

    1. The author's ego-stroking

    2. Claude's agentic capabilities show-case

    3. Memory safety (to be confirmed)

Google funding, I suspect. One day they will turn off the tap and the mantra will be silenced.

"Strange; seems like all I hear about these days are projects funded by the world's largest advertising corporation."