Comment by unrented7977
9 days ago
Meat isn't magical. There's nothing supernatural about a brain. It's all clockwork machinery all the way down.
A digital copy of a mind is no less alive than your children. They are, after all, nothing more than lossy copies of yourself.
But a digital copy of you isn't you.
I find I'm actually happier accepting a little nihilism in my life, knowing that at some point, I will die, and within a couple generations of my death, I will be completely forgotten.
This isn't depressing, it's freeing. It means there are no long term expectations of me, so I should I just spend as much time as I can doing the things I enjoy.
Distinction without a difference. My consciousness, my sense of self continues uninterrupted. There's no meaningful difference to me. You might care, but your opinion has zero weight on my own opinion of who and what I am.
One fudamentally cannot know the mind of another. Your opinion is based on incomplete observation and assumptions. Your insistence that a digital copy isn't me holds as much weight as the assertion that you aren't real because you exist only as text on my screen.
The religious would disagree. I'm not religious. How does this program or whatever running in my brain really work? I think it's just a biological thing, no magic juju thing.
If I could back it up to the web I would. If I could have saved my mom from her terrible disease and she was willing, and it was safe and not painful, I'd have with her permission copied her to some kind of system where she could see the world, enjoy being with her family, still be part of the world. I can imagine that happening but probably not in my lifetime. Not "a simulation" of the person, but a working psuedo brain.
> My consciousness, my sense of self continues uninterrupted.
That's the part I directly dispute.
I don't dispute that a computer could become conscious, but I'm not convinced you could transfer your consciousness to a machine. If a brain scan copied your brain, that would not be the same consciousness that you have now. It would be like having a twin, and twins don't share a consciousness.
1 reply →
I suppose parent comment is addressing the version of you that doesn't wake up inside a computer. If a biological vetsion of you exists, then that version won't be the same instance as the one in the machine. There will be two copies.
Machine-you would no doubt be thrilled. How does bio-you cope with not being made immortal? If your answer is "It doesn't matter, throw the original in the trash" is that murder or suicide?
I'd agree with the premise, but I had a different conclusion. For me realizing I'm going to die, emphasizes something else. We're on this Earth for an ridiculously brief moment in time. And as you age time only goes by faster and faster. And so to me it emphasized the need to make sure there's another generation of humans to come after us. It led to a bit of an obsession with fertility.
That's probably about as realistically close as we'll ever come to being able to transfer your consciousness. But it's even better than just transferring your consciousness because it comes with the added of benefit that the 'new you(s)' have every chance of being even better than you, especially if you pick a good quality partner and raise them well. I don't care if my distant progeny have any idea I ever existed, but I want to give them a chance to exist, and I'll always be some small part of them anyhow.
> But a digital copy of you isn't you.
I'll go further: a future biological you isn't necessarily you.
There's a continuity of being as we grow and age, but that's not enough to assert identity.
Identity is a useful (to our genes) mental fiction.
That doesn't mean that uploading is possible. The algorithm implemented in neurons likely depends heavily on specifics of neurons. One could implement something non-biological that would be similar, but similar isn't identical, and identical is what you'd need for uploading to look like "me going into silicon" and not "something that's kind of like what I was is now in silicon".
So why not just have a kid or two? A chatbot that sounds kind of like you did is no more 'you' than your kids are.
Then make a brain without access to other brains or things made by other brains.