Comment by jujube3
8 days ago
Dark matter would be a much better example of a possible modern-day Planet Vulcan. Although I don't think anyone has claimed to directly observe dark matter.
8 days ago
Dark matter would be a much better example of a possible modern-day Planet Vulcan. Although I don't think anyone has claimed to directly observe dark matter.
Dark matter is alright because it's less of a hypothesis than the lack of a hypothesis.
Sort of like if 19th century scientists would have just observed Mercury's perihelion advance and called it "dark perihelion" without postulating Vulcan or modified Newton or relativity.
> it's less of a hypothesis than the lack of a hypothesis
It does make one positive claim as a hypothesis: that we don't need to modify our model of gravity, only our model of particle physics.
Whereas MOND, the competing hypothesis, says we need to modify our model of gravity and not our model of particle physics.
Of course, it's also possible that we will end up needing to modify both.
In those terms, the planet Vulcan hypothesis was basically the analogue at the time of dark matter--whereas the eventual solution, General Relativity, was the analogue of MOND.
But note that General Relativity perfectly explained the observations and much else besides, whereas MOND falls rather flat on both.
1 reply →