← Back to context

Comment by wat10000

8 days ago

Is that true? That's not how I understood it, and sources I'm finding online seem to agree e.g. https://aas.org/posts/news/2017/08/month-astronomical-histor... and https://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/bitstream/handl....

It's at least true that many people reported seeing it. I think that's the point of calling this a "cautionary tale".

At this late date I would expect most accounts to be written as if it was obvious all along that "Vulcan" wasn't real. It was announced as discovered at one point, so it was not at all obvious at the time.